Friday, April 19, 2024

What Causes False Positive Hiv Test

What Is A False Negative Test Result

Australia’s COVID-19 vaccine causes false-positive HIV tests results

A false negative test result occurs when the test shows negative and the person is really HIV positive.

This is very rare and usually occurs during the window period when people are newly infected but the test cant quite pick up the infection.

As with other types of tests, there is always be a small margin of error. With antibody-only tests only 0.3% of tests will be a false negative after 3 months.

With 4th generation tests this is even lower. In practice, a negative result after six weeks means you do not have HIV.

You do not need to test again unless you have new risks in the future.

Herpes False Positive Test Results

There are many tests that can diagnose herpes, but some are more accurate than others. It is in fact possible to get a herpes false positive.

Positive Singles is a safe, supportive community to meet others with HSV! Dating profiles, blogs, support groups, and active discussion. Avoid the awkward herpes talk sign up free now.

Which test is best? First lets take a closer look at some of the tests and the overall effectiveness of each.

The Western Blot Test for Genital Herpes

This test is considered to be one of the most effective ways of diagnosing genital herpes, and it is thought that the test has great accuracy results. However, cost, time and availability are a major issue and this may make people turn to other types of herpes screening programs. Never the less, many physicians are willing to refer patients for a Western Blot test if they suspect an outbreak of genital herpes.

The HerpeSelect Test

This test comprises of two parts. Patients undergo the herpes immunoblot test and the genital herpes Elisa IgG test. The blood samples are analyzed at a laboratory, hence, the patient may have to wait for the test results. Both tests offer highly accurate results and as a rule, they will detect both variations of the herpes simplex virus . Recent studies show that herpes false positive results are unlikely when this type of test is used.

The SureVue HSV-2 Test

Dont Miss: How Do You Know If You Got Hiv

False Positive Hiv Due To P24 Antigen And Cd4 Lymphocytopenia

by Jason Wilson, MD, MA, FACEP, Heather Henderson, MA, CAS and Kaitlyn Pereira, BS | Jun 28, 2021

The likelihood of a false positive HIV test increases as the prevalence of HIV decreases and other potential explanations for the presence of p24 antigen become as prevalent as HIV. Often, patients with a false positive laboratory signature do not have other serum evidence of HIV infection. However, we will outline a case of a patient that underwent routine, ED-based HIV screening and had two false positive HIV tests on different dates , but also had a profound reduction of CD4 lymphocytes. There are several hypotheses to explain false positive screening results, including lupus, CAR T-cell therapy, rheumatoid arthritis, and other autoimmune diseases . Some have suggested a syndromic emergence of a Idiopathic CD4 lymphocytopenia, while others have suggested that it is common to have CD4+ lymphocytopenia with malaria, infections, stress, burns, malnutrition, over-exercising and pregnancy .

While in the ED, the patient underwent routine fourth generation HIV Ab/p24 Ag on the Abbot Architect, following CDC guidelines. Follow-up confirmatory HIV-1 and HIV-2 antibody test was negative on the Bio-Rad Geenius. An order was then placed for an HIV viral load via RNA PCR on the Hologic Aptima. No virus was detected. Testing was repeated, and the same laboratory signature was observed . The patient test results were ultimately classified as false positives.


Don’t Miss: Hiv 1 2 Antibodies

Do I Have To Retest For Hiv If The Result Was Negative

If a person gets tested for HIV within three months of being exposed to the virus and the result is negative, the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services recommends getting tested again in three months. For antigen/antibody tests, retesting can be done sooner, about 45 days after suspected exposure to HIV.

Transmission From Mother To Child

Conditions of false positive and false negative HIV test ...

Mothers can transmit HIV to their babies during pregnancy or delivery through vaginal fluids. Mothers who have HIV can also transmit the virus on to babies through their breast milk. However, many women who are living with HIV have healthy, HIV-negative babies by getting good prenatal care and regular HIV treatment.

Also Check: Does Cookie Johnson Have Hiv

Types And What They Assess

There are both indirect and direct methods of HIV detection. Indirect methods do not detect the virus but rather proteins, called antibodies, that are produced by the immune system in response to the virus. Direct testing methods detect either antigens or RNA .There are a few testing options, which vary in their speed, accuracy, and ease of use:

Any positive resultcalled the preliminary positivewould require a second confirmatory test to ensure the diagnosis is correct. The only exception is the NAT, which does require confirmation.

Results Of Confirmation Testing


The false positive rate for the first five months of confirmation testing using OIC for all double positive RDTs using Determine HIV-1/2 and Uni-Gold HIV was 10.3 percent out of a total of 2864 tested.


The proportion of double false positive RDTs on prospective testing using a confirmatory algorithm was zero of 43 tested.


In 2008, confirmation testing was introduced and in the first 15 months 29 of 407 false positives were prospectively identified.

Read Also: Hiv From Dried Blood

Type Of Hiv Test Used

Most testing sites use HIV antibody tests, called ELISA tests, for rapid screening of HIV. These tests detect antibodies that the body creates in response to an HIV infection.

However, many people also do rapid HIV testing using oral fluid and finger-prick tests. A 2017 study found that many children undergoing longstanding antiretroviral therapy received false-negative results from oral fluid tests.

Moreover, a 2018 review found that while self-testers often get reliable and accurate results, incorrect specimen collection is the most common error that affects the performance of these tests.

The same review mentioned that blood-based tests are more specific and reliable than oral fluid rapid tests. Despite this, many people prefer oral fluid tests for their convenience.Read more about ELISA tests here.

Reaction To Learning Of Their Misclassification

Vaccine trial in Australia leads to false positive HIV tests



Both patients were described as accepting the news well. One of the individuals however expressed regret as his wife had left him when she thought he was HIV positive.


Immediate reactions to the test results were not recorded systematically in Ethiopia. However all clients accepted their results, though several had difficulty understanding how this could have happened. Two individuals requested and received a letter from MSF to help prove to others that they had been falsely diagnosed.

You May Like: Hiv Without Ejaculation

Impact On Testing Volumes


The identification of misclassified individuals in the programme created immediate concern with the programme’s team about the public credibility of the testing programme. A press release describing the problem and the new quality control measures was released in February 2005. The monthly average number tested in the four months prior to the press release was similar to that tested in the four months immediately following the announcement .


Testing volumes for the four month period immediately before and after introduction of re-testing, were 432 and 703 respectively.


Mean monthly testing volumes for the four month period immediately before and after the introduction of re-testing were similar .

Identification Of Individuals In Hiv Programmes For Re


The first programme to re-test was in DRC where the introduction of CD4 monitoring in 2004 led to a group of six patients being identified as possibly having false positive HIV diagnoses on the basis of their relatively high CD4 counts and high CD4/CD8 ratios. All six were re-tested with two RDTs and found to be negative. A further group of 54 suspect patients was identified for re-testing using screening criteria of CD4 > 500 and no disease progression over one year.


Confirmation testing was introduced in 2007, and retrospective testing of all previously identified positives was done as the size of the cohort was small. Prior to re-testing, the counsellors received training from an experienced counsellor on how to support individuals receiving news of being falsely diagnosed HIV positive.


It was judged not feasible to re-test all the HIV patients in the programme at the time confirmation testing was introduced, so a high risk group was identified. Criteria were CD4 > 400, clinically stable or part of a discordant couple.

Read Also: Does Nba Youngboy Have Hiv

Technical Or Clerical Error

Mishandling samples, mislabeling, and mixing up specimens can occur during testing. At-home tests may also be prone to user error. Some testing devices may rely on subjective interpretation when reading a result, leading to incorrect interpretations when results are borderline.

of new HIV transmissions are from people who do not know that they have HIV.

The risk of HIV transmission depends on the behavior or exposure. The CDC measures a specific behaviors likelihood to transmit HIV for every 10,000 exposures.

Blood transfusion has the highest risk of transmitting HIV. Receptive anal sex, or receiving the penis into the anus, also increases transmission risk. A 2010 meta-analysis found a 1.4% risk of transmission, or 1 in every 71 exposures, from unprotected anal sex, regardless of whether the receptive person is male or female.

Needle sharing also carries some risk. A person has a chance of getting HIV when they share a needle with a person with the condition.

Why An Australian Covid

01.04 laboratory diagnosis and monitoring of hiv infection

ByRachael Rettnerpublished 11 December 20

Australian officials said they had canceled an order for some 51 million doses of the vaccine.

An Australian COVID-19 vaccine that had shown promising results in early trials is being abandoned after researchers found that the shot caused false-positive results on HIV tests.

On Friday , Australian officials said they had canceled an order for some 51 million doses of the vaccine, which was being developed by The University of Queensland and CSL Ltd., a local biotech company, according to The New York Times.

In an early trial with 216 participants, the vaccine appeared to be safe and to produce a robust immune response against COVID-19, according to a statement from CSL. But some volunteers falsely tested positive for HIV, which officials feared would undermine trust in the vaccine, the Times reported.

” was likely to work. But we knew that we didn’t want to have any issues with confidence, and this false-positive test may have caused some confusion and lack of confidence,” Brendan Murphy, secretary of Australia’s Department of Health, told the BBC.

20 of the worst epidemics and pandemics in history

The vaccine contained small fragments of an HIV protein, which helped stabilize the vaccine. Some of the participants developed antibodies against these fragments, and these antibodies triggered false positive results on some HIV tests.

Originally published on Live Science.

Read Also: Does Hiv Cause Hair Loss

Requesting A Genital Herpes Virus Test

Visit a physician and ask for a type-specific blood test. There are many herpes testing options but you are unlikely to have a false positive herpes test if you undergo one of the latest type-specific serological tests. A serological test for HSV can determine the difference between HSV-1 and HSV-2.

Anyone who fears they have received a herpes false positive test result may be exploring various other herpes testing options. Many experts agree that the molecular tests are best for diagnosing genital infections caused by the herpes simplex virus. Culture tests fail to detect the virus in many patients whereas the molecular test appears to confirm and clearly identify whether the person has HSV-1 or HSV-2.

Naturally, anyone who has been diagnosed with HSV will be concerned. If you feel that you have been handed a false positive herpes test result, you should discuss taking another test with your physician.

Dont Miss: How Long Does Hiv Last Outside The Body

Are Hiv Tests Accurate

Yes. Modern HIV tests are very accurate.

This accuracy has to be considered with the window period.

For example, 4th generation tests will pick up 99% of infections at six week.

Testing earlier, for example after four week, only detects 95% of infections. Testing earlier needs a confirmatory test three months after the risk.

A positive test result is routinely confirmed using a different type of test called western blot. The western blot test looks for immune responses to specific HIV proteins and is 100% accurate as a confirmatory test.

Can anything affect the result of my HIV test?

HIV antibody tests, confirmed by the second test, are not affected by other circumstances.

This includes infections, medications, most vaccinations, putting on weight, eating or drinking anything before the test, use of alcohol or recreational drugs, mouthwash or time of day.

Your test result is accurate even if you had flu or a cold or are using any medication.

You do not need to fast before your test. Food and drink do not affect the results.

Read Also: Can Hiv Lay Dormant

What Can Cause False Positive Elisa Hiv Tests

Ask U.S. doctors your own question and get educational, text answers â it’s anonymous and free!

Ask U.S. doctors your own question and get educational, text answers â it’s anonymous and free!

HealthTap doctors are based in the U.S., board certified, and available by text or video.

Finding The Cause Of A False

Australian vaccine cancelled after false positive HIV tests

Since there are various reasons for false-positive results, individuals should speak with a doctor about the probable cause. Some may be due to human error, such as a technical or clerical oversight.

However, a false-positive result can also result from another condition, such as an STI or an autoimmune disorder. Autoimmune disorders that may cause false-positive results include lupus and rheumatoid arthritis.

Don’t Miss: Cookie Johnson Hiv Positive

What Is A False Positive Hiv Test

False-Positive HIV Test Results False-Positive Results and Specificity When a person is not infected with HIV but receives a positive test result, that result is considered a false positive. Generally, HIV tests have high specificity, meaning that there are few false-positive results and most uninfected

False Positive Hiv Diagnoses In Resource Limited Settings: Operational Lessons Learned For Hiv Programmes

  • Affiliation Médecins Sans Frontières, Amsterdam, The Netherlands

  • Affiliation Médecins Sans Frontières, Amsterdam, The Netherlands

  • Affiliations Médecins Sans Frontières, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, Department of Medicine and Infectious Diseases, Royal Melbourne Hospital, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia

Recommended Reading: Does Cookie Johnson Have Aids

What Happens If I Test Positive

If the result from an initial HIV test is positive, a healthcare provider will order follow-up testing to learn if the result is accurate.

If the first test was conducted at home, a healthcare provider will draw a sample of blood to test in a lab. If the first test was done in a lab, follow-up testing may be conducted on the same blood sample at the lab.

If the second test result is positive, a healthcare provider can help explain the treatment options for HIV. Early diagnosis and treatment can help improve the long-term outlook and reduce the chances of developing complications from HIV.

Case Reportfalsely Positive Fourth Generation Advia Centaur Hiv Antigen/antibody Combo Assay In The Presence Of Autoimmune Hepatitis Type I


False positive results are common amongst fourth generation HIV screening assays.

A myriad of interferences can affect the overall sensitivity and specificity of testing.

Chronic liver disease is notable for causing false positive screening results.

Autoimmune hepatitis can produce false positive screening results.

You May Like: Can You Get Aids From Dried Blood

What You Can Do

If a healthcare provider makes an HIV diagnosis, they will help determine the best treatment. Treatments have become more effective over the years, making the virus more manageable.

Treatment can start right away to reduce or limit the amount of damage to the immune system. Taking medication to suppress the virus to undetectable levels in the blood also makes it virtually impossible to transmit the virus to someone else.

If a person receives a negative test result but isnt sure if its accurate, they should get retested. A healthcare provider can help determine what to do in this situation.

What Can Affect Your Test Results

HIV tests are highly sensitive and may result in a false positive. A follow-up test can determine whether a person truly has HIV. If the results from a second test are positive, a person is considered to be HIV-positive.

Its also possible to receive a false-negative result. This means the result is negative when in reality the virus is present. This generally happens if a person recently contracted HIV and gets tested during the window period. This is the time before the body has started producing HIV antibodies. These antibodies typically arent present until four to six weeks after exposure.

If a person receives a negative result but has reason to suspect that theyve contracted HIV, they should schedule a follow-up appointment in three months to repeat the test.

Read Also: Does Nba Youngboy Have Hiv

What Causes False Positive Results

HIV tests are based on the detection of antibodies to HIV. These are proteins produced by the immune system in response to a foreign substance, such as HIV. The main cause of false positive results is that the test has detected antibodies, but they are not antibodies to HIV they are antibodies to another substance or infection. Tests are not meant to react to other types of antibodies, but it sometimes happens.

There are other reasons why a test may give a false positive result. Depending on the testing device, reading the test result may rely on subjective interpretation. When the result is borderline, experienced staff give more consistently accurate results. A false positive result could also be the result of a sample being mislabelled, mixed up with another persons, or some other clerical or technical error.

Less commonly, false positive results may occur in people who have recently had a flu vaccine, are taking part in an HIV vaccine study, or have an autoimmune disease .

Popular Articles
Related news